With its companion program the high school public debate program hspdp, it is only debate format in the world requiring certification for event judges. Using a grading rubric as a debateproof strategy against the grade entitlement of students is expatiated. Score description argumentation refutation structure. Experiences and challenges of using a grading rubric in a social welfare policy course article pdf available in journal of teaching in social work 332. Objectives the public debate program is the only debate format in the world that requires judge certification for its competitions. It will contain the title of the debate event registration, the subject of the debate, as well as the date when the debate is held.
A grading rubric template is a type of tool used for assessment. Youll also describe the criteria for how you will evaluate their work. Middle school public debate program speaker point assessment rubric use half points 23. Speech and deba te union teachers guide to introducing debate in the classroom speech and deba te union page 3 of 29 pages generic debate format there are different types of debate and i t is important that you know what kind of debate yo u will be participati ng in. Philosophical debate needs work 1 not quite there 2 you did it 3 well doneimpressive 4 minimally evaluates a speakers point of view, reasoning, and use of evaluation of evidence and rhetoric, speakers point of view reasoning or exaggerated identifying any fallacious reasoning or exaggerated or distorted evidence. The debate should focus on the topic at hand and never on the people on the debate team. High school public debate program public debate program.
This rubric may be used for selfassessment and peer feedback. Edit it and use in a social studies, language arts, foreign language, science or reading class. Spoke and acted in a suitable manner by demonstrating a clear understanding of topic, addressing pertinent issues with suitable language and decorum, conveying an appreciation of and respect for the audience. Structured debate rubric criteria excellent 7 points good 5 points poor 3 points post 1 original post the teams first post was well thought out, details and defined the issue. Debate notes and format w rubric linkedin slideshare. The middle school public debate program mspdp certifies all judges for its debate competitions. Online discussion rubric criteria unsatisfactory 0 limited 1 proficient 2 exemplary 3 score critical analysis understanding of readings and outside references discussion postings show little or no evidence that readings were completed or understood. Most information presented in the debate was clear and accurate, but. Lhs persuasiveargument writing rubric liberty high school. Pdf this article discusses the experiences and challenges of a. Koshy have spent summers traveling the country, teaching students about lincolndouglas debate. Holding debates in middle school classes thoughtco.
Not only does effective team planning allow for a deeper level of professional development, but it also leads to increased student achievement. Debate scoring rubric california area school district. A topic set for the theme of mobile technology is shown here. Having said the above, deduct marks for offensive ad hominem arguments. Debate briefs should be collected and checked by the instructor. Help in guiding and developing novice debaters is an inherent part of the class work. Debate rubric 3 2 1 viewpoint viewpoints are clear and organized. Score description argumentation refutation structure presentation 21 and below. You can use this template to articulate what excellent work looks like. This should serve as the first section of a debate evaluation form.
Each topic set should contain three to five related topics. Use the following list for great ideas in middle school debate topics. Mspdp judge training and rubric the middle school public debate program mspdp certifies all judges for its debate competitions. Pick your topic wisely, ensuring that it is acceptable for middle school students. Make sure to build consequences into the debate rubric. Koshy both debated for apple valley high school in minnesota during the 1990s and were the two minnesota state champions from apple valley during that decade. The post stated the stance clearly at the beginning and provided data or references to support the. Most information presented in the debate was clear, accurate and thorough. The post stated the stance clearly at the beginning and provided data or references to support the stance. Contributed to the success of the debate by preparing outside of class, making prepared speeches, and responding spontaneously to questions and challenges. Students should be able to view the rubric, judge ballots, and their debate. The debate grade will be based on the quality of debating done by the stude debate tips middle school high school speech and debate argumentative essay public speaking rubrics lesson plans homeschooling. Use these worksheet to learn how to debate and how to prepare for a debate. For advanced students, you can use a list for high school students publish your rubric before the debate.
Debate scoring sheet eleanor roosevelt high school. Talked or whispered repeatedly while others were debating. Edie wagner, in professional studies, is the coordinator and. It can be used for most any speech, however it was created for a special occasion speech. This rubric category sets expectations for and assesses how well the student understands the debate topic. This table can be used to judge the quality and techniques other debaters are using to convey their points. There are some things, however, that all debate formats have in common. Main arguments and responses are outlined in a clear and orderly way.
Classroom debate worksheets for middles grades and high school. A debate is a discussion or structured contest about an issue or a resolution. Students may begin judging middle school debates in the 10th grade. The subject of the debate can either be presented in a form of a question or a bullet for separate topics per competing pair. Mspdp judge training and rubric public debate program.
Dec 02, 2014 basic debate format slides for high school public speaking. In most high school tournament settings, policy team debate involves learning about, and discussing, real world problems and solutions, essentially boiling down to. A debate evaluation form is similar to a scorecard that the judges will use at any competition, however, it will indicate an indepth description of the evaluators thoughts about the presentation evaluation of the participants ideas. The team made a clear presentation of the panelists basic position outstanding. Rubric for the assessment of the argumentative essay. Students are involved in detailed and extensive analysis of debate theory and technique with application of skills in competition. Debate assessment rubric blm g15 debating team name and position. Debate rubric 2010 each student in the debate will be graded individually.
Start at 22 and go up from there m i d d l e s c h o o l p u b l i c d e b a t e p r o g r a m middle school public debate program. Instructional guide niu center for innovative teaching. This is a general study of the techniques of interscholastic debate. Return this rubric to tony narkawizc at the institutional research office.
If using the student position handout, be sure to provide some time for completion of the initial position 3. Debates may be judged in order to declare a winning side. Instead, both teachers and school leaders should brainstorm collaborative structures that would allow teams to plan across contents and areas of specialty. Speaker point assessment rubric use half points 23.
The speakers statements clearly supported their position in the debate. Teachers guide to introducing debate in the classroom. Youll find debate topics, information on how to debate and graphic organizers to help students organize their thinking around their debate. Student cannot answer questions about subject matter student seems to understand a little bit about the topic student is able. These worksheets support higher level thinking in the classroom. General debate ballot for lay judges free rubric builder and assessment tools. Free oral communication rubrics teachers pay teachers.
Rebuttal should contain reasonably valid arguments rather. It will serve as the rubrics of the judges with regards to indicating whether their standards have been met by the. Browse our rubric examples for subjects like art, social studies, and math, as well as skills like writing and literary. High school speech and debate judging basics and event. Basic debate format slides for high school public speaking. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. Discussion rubric examples northwestern university. Evidence for this score should be found in the specific points raised during the debate. Public debate program judge training and rubric high school public debate program format grades 9th 12th 201617 overview this guide is designed for new and experienced judges attending high school public debate program hspdp competitions. Slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Showed confidence and preparation through body language, vocal inflection. The rubric assesses the teams performance, as well as the individual team members performance and contributions to the debate.
You can use it to express your expectations regarding the work of your students. Rubrics are a valuable tool to speed up grading and clarify expectations. This guide is a brief compilation of teachingrelated information from several sources, including instructional guidebooks from other institutions, journals, and contributions from master teachers and academic support units at northern illinois university. Conducting a debate tn a debate is a discussion or structured contest about an issue or a resolution. Debate rubric each student in the debate will be graded individually. Oral presentation rubric 4excellent 3good 2fair 1needs improvement delivery holds attention of entire audience with the use of direct eye contact, seldom looking at notes speaks with fluctuation in volume and inflection to maintain audience interest and emphasize key points consistent use of direct eye contact with. The debate grade will be based on the quality of debating done by the students, not whether the team won or lost the debate.
Middle school public debate program public debate program. Such a debate is bound by rules previously agreed upon. Apply this rubric to any object and invite others to assess. High school debate curriculum park hill school district.